Italy was a victor of the Great War, but not of the peace. It did not reap the rewards it had been promised and was instead plunged into an economic crisis and political instability. This ‘mutilated peace’ as it became known led to a long period of strikes, factory occupations and lockouts, and widespread rural unrest. Violence and intimidation were the order of the day it seemed and political assassination was commonplace while a succession of weak governments incapable of bridging the political divide looked on helplessly unable to cope.
The ‘Biennio Rosso’ had pushed Italy towards revolution on the model of Bolshevik Russia with Worker’s Soviets being established in Turin, Milan, and other major cities while efforts were made to forcibly collectivise the land. It left much of Italy traumatised as the property of the rich was seized without compensation while the poor denied their labour were likewise denied their pay. In the meantime, militias of both the left and right imposed their own version of rough justice unimpeded by the intervention from the legitimate forces of law and order. It seemed as if the government’s remit simply didn’t run.
The people were desperate for order and prayed for stability but from where would it come? Who would provide it?
On 30 October 1922, some 30,000 black shirted fascisti marched through Rome to demand their leader Benito Mussolini be made Prime Minister, even though King Victor Emmanuel had already appointed him such the previous day; but the march was intended to be a show of force, the armed seizure of power. Many people came onto the streets to welcome them, many more intimidated stayed at home, some were beaten up and 12 were killed.
Fearing trouble from his political opponents, and worse that the army might intervene, Mussolini remained safely in Milan. Now he hurried to Rome to be present at the moment of his greatest triumph.
The March on Rome, the coup that never was, soon etched itself into fascist mythology, the 30,000 became 300,000, the fascist dead nil at the time would soon be counted in the thousands. Few were interested in the facts it seemed merely the spectacle and upon the young leader of a fledgling political party in nearby Germany it had a profound effect.
Adolf Hitler had become leader of the National Socialist German Workers’ Party (NSDAP) on 29 July 1921, only two years after joining its predecessor the German Workers’ Party (DAP) in what in effect was a coup of his own. The DAP’s outstanding speaker he increased the membership, sold out the halls, and filled the party coffers. Having resigned leaving them bereft he only returned on condition he was made leader and received full authority over and control of the party.
Hitler demanding absolute obedience governed his party with a rod of iron. He would later develop this into the ‘Fuhrer Principle,’ but for now he was a man in a hurry. He believed, even though the Nazi Party as it became known had little in the way of a national presence, that if he seized power in Bavaria and marched from there on Berlin as Mussolini had on Rome then he likewise would be able to overthrow the government.
Ever since the end of the Great War Germany had lurched from one crisis to another, unstable government, mass unemployment, violent political disorder, and hyperinflation. Reparations imposed on Germany by the victorious Allied powers intended to pay the war indemnity saw the government print money in a desperate attempt to not to default on the repayments and stave off the further seizure of assets and resources. Instead, it caused unprecedented hyperinflation which saw the mark become effectively worthless and wrecked the economy. Savings were wiped out, savings were wiped out, fixed-income assets lost all value. Paper money became so worthless workers were paid multiple times a day, a cup of coffee could double in price from the time you ordered it to the moment you received it, and a loaf of bread cost 200 billion marks.
By late November 1923 hyperinflation had peaked at 4.2 trillion marks to the dollar and people were not using a purse for their money but a wheelbarrow. The barter of goods had become a more common form of currency than the exchange of paper money while unemployment continued to rise near 15% adding further to the queues of the starving at the soup kitchens seen in towns and cities across the country.
There was then little love for the Weimar Republic from anywhere on the political spectrum there never had been, and a coup was always likely, but where and by whom?
The leaders of Bavaria’s most right-wing political parties who had earlier formed the Kampf Bund or Battle League to overthrow the Weimar Government and punish the so-called ‘November Criminals’ responsible for Germany’s defeat and humiliation were meeting on the night of 7 November to coordinate and finalise their plans. Among those present were General Ludendorff the man who had so nearly won the war for Germany and remained a hero to many on the right, Dr Friedrich Weber leader of the Oberland League, and Adolf Hitler accompanied by Hermann Goering.
The perfect opportunity for a coup would present itself the following night at the Burgerbraukeller in Munich, a large beer cellar and restaurant complex situated on the south bank of the River Isar about half-a-mile from the city centre where Gustave Ritter von Kahr, the recently appointed State Commissioner for Bavaria would be addressing a public meeting. Accompanying him would be General Otto von Lassow, commander of the Bavarian army who had been reinstated to his position by Kahr having earlier been sacked by the government in Berlin, and Colonel Hans von Seisser, chief of the State Police. The head of the snake as Hitler described them all in the one place at the same time, and the plan conceived to sever that head was very much his:
Key installations throughout the city of Munich would be seized while the Burgerbraukeller would be surrounded and sealed off by up to 600-armed SA men. The Bavarian triumvirate would then be taken prisoner and forced to recognise the formation of a new government in Bavaria which would then endorse a march on Berlin and the overthrow of the Reich Government there.
The clock was striking 8pm as the gleaming red Mercedes carrying Hitler and his companions drew up outside the Burgerbraukeller, but despite the small gathering of party men there to receive them they did not immediately announce their presence but instead waited in the lobby of the building while Kahr continued to speak in the main hall. In an atmosphere of heightened tension only made worse by a clearly agitated Hitler pacing nervously around the room Putzi Hanfstaengl, an ever-present on the fringes of the Nazi inner-circle purchased three litre jugs of beer at a billion marks each. It did little to help as all waited anxiously for Hitler to give the command. At last, he did so, the state commissioner had droned on long enough, and so the double doors were thrown open and Hermann Goering stormed through accompanied by 25 SA men armed with machine guns while others took up position inside the hall. Witnessing the sight of so many armed men caused pandemonium in the hall as tables were overturned and glasses smashed in the attempt to flee. But they could not all the exits had been blocked off.
Hitler and his bodyguard now forced a way through the mass of confused and frightened people and onto the speaker’s platform. He shouted from the people to be quiet, but they paid no attention so he climbed onto a chair to ensure he could be seen and did so again, but still they paid him no heed so taking his pistol from its holster he fired it into the air. That got their attention. Stunned into silence Hitler now began to speak his voice trembling with emotion:
“The national revolution has broken out in the whole of Germany. This hall is occupied by six-hundred-armed men, and no one may leave it. Reichswehr and State Police are marching under our banner from their barracks; a national German and Bavarian government is being formed; the Bavarian and Reich government are deposed.”
This was the moment! His eyes blazed with intensity as he shunted Kahr, Lassow, and Seisser into a side room. There he told them in no uncertain terms they could either join the revolution or be shot. It was a binary choice there could be no equivocation. Still the three men remained remarkably calm given the circumstances neither committing to the coup nor opposing it. Hitler assuming their compliance informed them of their new roles. Kahr would be Regent in the absence of the Crown Prince, Lassow Reichswehr Minister, and Seisser Reich Police Minister. He, Hitler, would be Reich Chancellor and General Ludendorff chief of the German Army.
Hitler now returned to the main hall where he quelled the restless crowd with a speech many later described as one of the most spellbinding of his entire career.
In the meantime, Ludendorff had arrived and proved no less persuasive, or so it seemed, in convincing Kahr, Lassow, and Seisser to support the revolution. At 9.40 pm all three men returned to the speaker’s platform to publicly pledge their support.
While everything appeared to be going to plan in the Burgerbraukeller elsewhere in the city the plot was beginning to unravel. The streets of Munich were teeming with SA men as intended, but the key installations had not been seized instead they seemed more interested in hunting down Jews, beating up their political opponents, and carousing in the local bars. Meanwhile, and contrary to Hitler’s previous assertion, neither the army nor the state police had rallied in his support. The situation required his personal intervention he believed, so it was now he decided to leave the Beer Cellar for the short drive into the city centre – it was a mistake. In his absence Ludendorff permitted Kahr and his colleagues to leave also, on their word of honour to do as previously pledged and to return when sent for.
The released men returned to their various headquarters and though they did not act immediately, they did act. At 1 am Kahr issued the following statement:
“Deception and breach of faith by certain ambitious characters turned a demonstration for Germany’s reawakening into repulsive scenes of force and violence. Declarations extorted from me, General Lassow, and Colonel von Seisser by pistol point are null and void.”
He then ordered the dissolution of the Nazi Party and those groups associated with it and removed the Bavarian Government from Munich to Regensburg.
Two hours later General Lassow issued a statement of his own:
“State Commissioner Kahr, Colonel Seisser, and General Lassow repudiate the Hitler Putsch. Expressions of support extracted at gunpoint are invalid.”
It was clear the three men who were pivotal to Hitler’s plan to seize and hold onto power in Bavaria and then Germany had reneged on their previous support for the putsch and now openly opposed it.
Meanwhile, things were also stirring in Berlin where President Ebert ordered General von Seeckt in command of the Reichswehr to use any means at his disposal to suppress the revolt. He in turn angrily phoned General Lassow in Munich telling him in no uncertain terms to end the revolt now – “You do it – or I will!”
Hitler was no less paralysed by indecision, the people had not rallied to the coup as he had expected, Munich had not been locked down as planned, and many Nazi Party members informed late of Hitler’s intentions had yet to arrive in the city. Worse still, they had already crossed the Rubicon, treason had been committed and treason was a hanging offence. But what to do? It was General Ludendorff, whose sense of honour had in large part been the cause of the coup’s initial failure, who came up with the solution. They must gather at the Burgerbraukeller for a march to the city centre in a show of force. Surely then all would fall into line.
On the morning of 9 November, a cold grey day but one now ominous in its intensity around 2,000 Nazi Party members, SA men, and their allies gathered outside the Burgerbraukeller. Many were armed with pistols, and all feared they might have to use them. It was thought however or at least hoped that neither the police nor the army would dare fire upon the illustrious Ludendorff who marched at the head of the column, eight abreast with Hitler to his right and Goering to his left.
Few it seemed truly believed in the likelihood of success and a series of police blockades established along the marcher’s route only added to the sense of gloom that was beginning to prevail. However, spirits were raised when the first police blockade they encountered allowed them to pass unimpeded. They perked up further at the indications of support coming from onlookers and the occasional shouted Heil Hitler! heard above the cacophony of whistles and catcalls that had accompanied them thus far.
The nearer they approached the centre of the city the greater support for the march appeared to get. As they entered the Marienplatz it was to cheers as swastika flags became visible and SA men could be seen emerging from buildings. As they neared the Odeonsplatz and closed in on the Feldernhalle however, they were blocked by a heavily armed police presence with a commander determined to stop them as ordered.
The presence of General Ludendorff was brought to the attention of the police, but it made no difference and a tense stand-off ensued. It was broken by a shot being fired. No one can say for sure who fired it, but it mattered little now as shots were exchanged in a furious if brief firefight. It lasted barely a minute but in that short time 16 of the marchers and 4 policemen were killed. Hitler, like the good ex-soldier he was had instinctively thrown himself onto the ground at the first sound of gunfire dislocating his shoulder in the process. He was quickly ushered into a nearby car and spirited away from the scene. He had been lucky, the man standing beside him had been shot dead. Hermann Goering had been shot in the groin but managed to escape in the pandemonium that followed, soon after fleeing abroad. Ludendorff however, along with his adjutant, continued on his way stiff-backed and unflinching right up to the police lines where he was promptly arrested before being allowed home on his word of honour not to flee. He had not been fired upon.
Hitler was arrested two days after the march having taken refuge at the country estate of the omnipresent Putzi Hansfstaengl. He had expected to be shot but was instead taken to Landsberg Prison and charged with high treason, along with General Ludendorff and eight others.
Hitler’s trial for high treason began in Munich on 24 February 1924, it was only one of many taking place around this time but the national press was very much focused on the fate of the Nazi Party leader and his more illustrious fellow revolutionary (the term would have horrified him) General Ludendorff.
Fortunate to be subject to the due process of law, a luxury denied others who had behaved similarly in recent years, Hitler defending himself was determined to subvert proceedings by putting the Reich Government and the ‘November Criminals’ on trial. He was helped in this by a divided and often favourable press and a sympathetic Judge presiding, Georg Neithardt, who if not an out-and-out admirer of Hitler certainly was of Ludendorff.
The trial lasted a week and Hitler dominated proceedings throughout. The evidence against him was damning it was true, but those vocalising it for the prosecution were no less culpable it seemed. Kahr, Lassow, and Seisser their principal witnesses had been planning a similar coup of their own for months and everyone knew it. Hitler seized upon this fact and pursued it relentlessly. Indeed, it became a feature of the trial how he was permitted to lecture and harangue the Court for hours at a time without any push back or interruption. It was his summing up however, that would make headlines around the world and dominate the press for days to come:
“Gentlemen, judgement will not be passed on us by you; judgement will be passed on us by the eternal court of history. This court will judge the accusations that have been made against us. That other court, however, will not ask: ‘Did you or did you not commit high treason?’ That court will pass judgement on us, on the General in command of the Quartermaster Corps of the old army, on his officers and soldiers, who as Germans wanted the best for their people and their country, who were willing to fight and die for it. Even if you find us guilty a hundred times over, the goddess of the eternal tribunal of history will smilingly tear apart the proposal of the Prosecutor and the sentence of the Court, because she will acquit us.”
The People’s Court of Bavaria did not acquit him, but the sentence passed was as lenient as it could reasonably have been. For the crime of High Treason against the State, he was sentenced to five years in prison with the possibility of early release after just six months. He would in fact serve just nine months. His partner in crime General Ludendorff who had relied upon the dignity of his rank, word of honour as an officer and a gentleman, and political naivety for his defence was acquitted of all charges, but that was always going to be the case.
Hitler’s incarceration was hardly a harsh one and as frustrating as being removed from the day-to-day politics of the Weimar Republic may have been he actually quite enjoyed it. Having temporarily ceded leadership, if not control of the Nazi Party to Alfred Rosenberg (he would be back soon enough) he proceeded to dictate the story of his political struggles thus far Mein Kampf to his secretary Rudolf Hess, took walks in the grounds, met admirers, and held meetings of party members. He also absorbed and learned the lessons of his failed putsch. He would no longer seize power by force but would instead, if not exactly via the ballot box, manipulate the system in place thereby using against it the vagaries of a democracy ripe for exploitation.
But he continued to admire without reservation Benito Mussolini for his March on Rome and having the leadership qualities and strength of will achieve what he had not. It was the deed of a warrior and by behaving so he had become a hero of history that he, the future Fuhrer, could never now be.
Share this post: